738 Edits since joining this wiki
February 10, 2009
  • Agent0042
    • That the Inheritance Cycle is too derivative of other works.
    Legitimate? The strength of the series comes not from its similarities, but from its differences. Each series includes "Tropes" that are common to all works. If the series contains something that is similar, it may simply be homage, especially if names or circumstances are exactly the same. Keep in mind that much of Star Wars is based on The Hidden Fortress.
    • Warfare - Fun
    Legitimate? - See my own addition to that section. Some of the other concerns in this section may be legitimate, but I am willing to dismiss them as minor.
    • Language
    Legitimate? Maybe, but I am willing to dismiss these as minor and certain issues may be still be later addressed.
    • Science
    Legitimate? Hardly. Is this coming fr…
    Read more >

Also on Fandom

Random Wiki